            Subj:RE: A couple more harmonization proposals 
            Date:5/15/2003 9:19:41 AM Pacific Daylight Time
            From:lmckenzi@ca.ibm.com
            To:woody@beelers.com
            CC:mnm@lists.hl7.org
            Received from Internet: 




Hi Woody,

I'd be perfectly happy with QueryEvent.statusCode being changed to
non-Mandatory.

Items 3-5 are hereby withdrawn and should be replaced with the following:

Remove the classCode reference for QueryEvent.  This is a hold-over from
when QueryEvent *used* to be descended from Act.  QueryEvent no longer has
a classCode attribute, and therefore shouldn't have a classCode reference.


Lloyd

Lloyd McKenzie, P.Eng.              I/T Architect, IBM Global Services
Internet: LMCKENZI@CA.IBM.COM
PhoneMail: (780)421-5620          Internal Mail: 04/QBG/1004 /EDM


"George Beeler" <woody@beelers.com>@lists.hl7.org on 2003-05-15 08:42:44 AM

Please respond to "George Beeler" <woody@beelers.com>

Sent by:    owner-mnm@lists.hl7.org


To:    Lloyd McKenzie/CanWest/IBM@IBMCA, <mnm@lists.hl7.org>
cc:
Subject:    RE: A couple more harmonization proposals


Lloyd -

In re item# 1 -- More directly, SHOULD QueryEvent.statusCode be Mandatory?
I do not believe it should.  This is not a structural attribute, and, so
far, only structural attributes have been mandatory in the RIM.

Item #2 is OK

Item #3-5 are all incorrect, because QueryEvent is NOT a specialization of
Act.

Woody

George W. Beeler, Jr. Ph.D.
Beeler Consulting LLC
807 Tenth Ave. SW
Rochester, MN 55902-6357  USA

email: woody@beelers.com
voice: 507-254-4810 (& voice mail)
fax: 507-281-8951


> -----Original Message-----
> From: owner-mnm@lists.hl7.org
> [mailto:owner-mnm@lists.hl7.org] On Behalf Of Lloyd McKenzie
> Sent: Wednesday, May 14, 2003 2:48 PM
> To: mnm@lists.hl7.org
> Subject: A couple more harmonization proposals
>
>
> I believe these are all technical corrections
>
> 1. QueryEvent.statusCode minimum cardinality should be '1'
> (not '0').  This attribute is marked as mandatory, and
> mandatory attributes must have a minimum cardinality of '1'.
>
> 2. QueryEvent.statusCode should be CNE, not CWE.  The
> datatype is 'CS', and all 'CS' attributes must be CNE
>
> 3. QueryEvent should not have an associated
> stateAttributeName (which is currently 'statusCode') because
> it inherits this from Act.
>
> 4. The QMSG ActClassCode accidentally got toasted
>
> 5. We need classCodes (and associations to their relevant
> physical classes)
> for:
> QueryAck - QACK
> QueryContinuation - QCONT
> QuerySpec - QSPC
> QueryByParameter QPAR
> QueryBySelection - QSEL
>
> Lloyd McKenzie, P.Eng.              I/T Architect, IBM Global Services
> Internet: LMCKENZI@CA.IBM.COM
> PhoneMail: (780)421-5620          Internal Mail: 04/QBG/1004 /EDM
>
>
>
> ---
> To access the Mailing List archives, go to:
> http://lists.hl7.org/lyris.pl?enter=mnm
>
>



---
To access the Mailing List archives, go to:
http://lists.hl7.org/lyris.pl?enter=mnm







---
To access the Mailing List archives, go to: 
http://lists.hl7.org/lyris.pl?enter=mnm


